Postal 98 Cafe LLC Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Postal 98 Cafe LLC, a charming eatery nestled in the heart of Sarasota, Florida. This cafe combines Mennonite warmth with a hint of New York sophistication, making it a cozy retreat for locals and visitors alike.
Our seasonal drinks are a highlight, with delightful options like the Toffee Cold Foam Latte and the Cookie Butter Cold Foam Latte. For those seeking a bite, our cold sandwiches are crafted with quality ingredients, such as the Toasted BLT on sourdough and the Roast Beef Special with our signature horseradish sauce.
At Postal 98, we pride ourselves on cleanliness and friendliness, as echoed by our loyal patrons. Whether you’re here for a refreshing coffee or a satisfying meal, you'll find a welcoming ambiance and delicious choices that make every visit a delight.
Tea NO LABEL
Cold Brew
Iced Green Tea-
Sweet Tea
Unsweet Iced Black Tea-
Hot Tea-
Granola Bar
Bottled Water
K-Cups 6 Pack
Chocolate Milk
Orange Juice - Pint
Chips
Seasoned Pretzels
Reading Soda
Cold Brew- 8oz.(4 Bags)
Retail
Pastries
Muffins
Cookies
Cheese Tarts
Whoopie Pies
Macarons
Macarons (6 Or More)
Croissant
Turkey Special
Served Cold On Sourdough Bread With Coleslaw & Our Own Russian Dressing
Roast Beef Special
Served On Sourdough Bread With Our Own Horseradish Sauce
Sweet Lebanon Bologna Sandwich
Served On Sourdough With Smoked Cheddar Cheese & Mayo
Sweet Bologna-Create Your Own
Turkey- Create Your Own
Roast Beef-Create Your Own
Ham-Create Your Own
Corned Beef- Create Your Own
Cheese Sandwich- Create Your Own
Toasted BLT
Served On Sourdough Bread With Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mozzarella Cheese & Pesto Mayo
2oz Side Of Coleslaw
2oz Side Of Russian Dressing
2oz Side Of Caribbean Sauce
Cold Sandwiches
Hot Panini Sandwiches
Country Ham & Swiss Cheese Panini
Roast Beef & Swiss Cheese Panini
Served On Sourdough Bread With Our Own Horseradish Sauce
Turkey & Basil Pesto Panini
Served On Sourdough Bread With Muenster Cheese & Tomato
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Served On Sourdough Bread With Sharp American Cheese
Grams Caribbean Chicken Wrap
Served On A White Tortilla with Chicken, Bacon, Muenster Cheese, Tomato & Our Homemade Sweet And Spicy Sauce
2oz Side Of Russian Dressing
2oz Side Of Coleslaw
2oz Side Of Caribbean Sauce
Grilled Corned Beef Special
Served On Sourdough Bread With Swiss Cheese, Coleslaw & Our Own Russian Dressing
Bacon, Egg, Cheese
Sausage, Egg And Cheese
Item only available till 12:00pm
Ham, Egg, Cheese
Served On Sourdough Bread w/ Our Own Honey Dijonnaise Sauce
Egg & Cheese
Item only available till 12:00pm
Avocado Mash
Half Order Avocado Mash
Yogurt Partfait
Fruit Cup
Plain Bagel
Toast- 2pieces
Toast With Avocado- 1 Piece
Dave's Special
Ham, Egg & Cheese On An Everything Bagel With Tomato & Mayo *Item only available till 12:00pm*
Two Scrambled Eggs
Item only available till 12:00pm