Welcome to Postal 98 Cafe LLC
Nestled at 1240 Yoder Ave in Sarasota, FL, Postal 98 Cafe LLC exudes a charming blend of Mennonite warmth and New York flair. This cozy café specializes in a variety of cold sandwiches, including the standout Roast Beef Special on sourdough, paired with house-made horseradish sauce, and the delightful Sweet Lebanon Bologna with smoked cheddar. Patrons rave about the welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff. The café also excels in coffee offerings, highlighted by fan favorites like Tanisha's Toffee Frappe and Bella's Caramel Macchiato. With a commitment to cleanliness and quality, Postal 98 Cafe is a must-visit for both locals and visitors seeking a vibrant yet laid-back dining experience.
-
1240 Yoder Ave, Sarasota, FL 34239, United States1240 Yoder Ave, Sarasota, FL 34239, United States Hotline: +1 941-260-8862
Welcome to Postal 98 Cafe LLC, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Sarasota, Florida. Located at 1240 Yoder Ave, this cafe beautifully blends cozy Mennonite charm with a subtle New York vibe, creating an inviting atmosphere that beckons both locals and visitors alike. As soon as you step inside—or onto one of the shaded outdoor tables—you'll feel a sense of warmth and community that makes this spot truly special.
The heart of Postal 98 lies in its delicious offerings. The menu is a rich tapestry of flavors, featuring hot panini sandwiches like the Grams Caribbean Chicken Wrap, which is a scrumptious combination of chicken, bacon, Muenster cheese, and a homemade sweet and spicy sauce, all wrapped in a tender white tortilla. Another standout is the Grilled Corned Beef Special, a fulfilling meal served on hearty sourdough with Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and a tangy Russian dressing. For lovers of simple comforts, the classic Grilled Cheese Sandwich features sharp American cheese melted perfectly on sourdough bread.
If you're in the mood for something refreshing, pair your meal with one of their thoughtfully crafted smoothies or spritzers. The 98 Classic, a delightful mix of strawberry and pineapple, promises to invigorate your palate, while the Strawberry Mint Spritzer offers a unique twist, all at an affordable price of US$5.99.
No meal at Postal 98 is complete without indulging in their selection of pastries. Treat yourself to a Whoopie Pie or a Cheese Tart; these sweet delights range from US$1.99 to US$2.75 and provide a perfect ending to your dining experience.
The ambiance of the cafe only adds to its allure. Guests have described it as a peaceful escape, ideal for quiet conversations or relaxing moments with a good book. The cleanliness is impeccable—a point praised by many, ensuring that the dining experience is as comforting as the food itself. Patrons have noted that the friendly staff enhances the overall experience, making each visit not just a meal but a welcoming encounter.
Whether you're a local or just passing through Sarasota, Postal 98 Cafe LLC is a must-visit destination for those seeking quality coffee, delicious food, and an inviting atmosphere. So, gather your friends, bring your family, or simply enjoy a cozy moment alone, and discover why this cafe has become a beloved spot in the community.
For inquiries, you can reach them at +1 941-260-8862. Just remember that they are closed on Sundays, so plan your visit wisely!
Tucked away with a cozy Mennonite charm and a subtle New York vibe, this spot is one of my Sarasota favorites. Whether you’re grabbing a bite or just want to sip on a delicious coffee drink, this is the place. Indoor seating is limited, but there are plenty of shaded outdoor tables—perfect for a quiet catch-up with friends, a peaceful solo moment with a book, or a laid-back lunch. I’ve been here with my 5-year-old and her best friend—both picky eaters—and they not only found something to eat, but actually enjoyed it. I’ve also brought my mom, grandma, and best friend on different occasions. It’s become a bit of a go-to for me, even with all the amazing places Sarasota has to offer. I have a lot of allergies, and I’ve never once felt unwell after eating here. That says a lot about their cleanliness and ingredient care. The staff is always friendly and kind. You can see right into the cooking area, and everything is spotless—floors, bathroom, the air (no chemical smells!). It’s just a genuinely good, clean, welcoming place with great food and even better vibes.
I love this spot so much! Personally, this is the best coffee spot in SRQ. It’s quiet, quality, and consistently good. I get the Cobes sweet cream cold brew every time. They are always closed on Sundays so be aware of that.
The drinks and cookie in this little outstanding shop are always delicious. The service is also always wonderful and those who work there are always friendly. To top it off they have a points system where you can earn free food/drinks if you go enough. Spoiler alert...we go enough. Whether you are local or visiting Sarasota you definitely want to make sure you stop and enjoy some of their excellent offerings.
Great local spot for a delicious coffee and decent bites for breakfast. Tried the siesta iced latte which I subbed the white mocha for regular mocha to make an almond joy type drink with the coconut that was in it. My wife and I split the avocado mash and bacon egg and cheese wrap. Enjoyed sitting in the shade in the alley
Wow! I love this amazing coffee shop! So cute and their coffee is amazing! Definitely make sure you stop in when you're in Sarasota. ...
One of the cutest little coffee shops in the area. Such cute decor, amazing baked goodies, and coffee that’s unlike mainstream burnt beans! Definitely have to try this place and support local when you can! Small bar inside to sit but lots of outdoor seating.
You MUST visit this place!! One of the best places for a morning espresso drink. I got a Cortado and it was super yummy. Staff super friendly and the atmosphere is so chill that you simply want to hang out. Very euro street cafe vibe. Highly recommend.
This is beyond a hidden GEM of Sarasota. I have been going here for years and it's one of my favorites for breakfast, lunch, coffee, merch, desserts, and more. It's a small little cafe, with a decent amount of outside seating. The food and coffee is just out of this world- and I constantly am buying their snacks, clothing, glassware, and items from the small inside section too. Only complaint I have is the parking, but I usually park on the other side of Yoders and walk. 10000/10 stars.